top of page

All Beliefs Are Wrong? How Beliefs Shape Our Reality

Writer: Anil Thomas
Anil Thomas
Jun 7, 2021
13 min read

Updated: Oct 23


FACT AND BELIEF




Our beliefs influence how we interpret the world, make decisions and understand ourselves. Many of these beliefs develop through childhood experiences, family, culture, education and the people around us. Over time, we may begin to treat them as unquestionable truths, even when they are based on limited information or personal assumptions. But does that mean all beliefs are wrong? Perhaps the more useful question is whether we are willing to examine our beliefs, question where they came from and change them when evidence or experience calls for it.


“We learn our belief systems as very little children, and then we move through life creating experiences to match our beliefs. Look back in your own life and notice how often you have gone through the same experience.”

— Louise L. Hay


How Do We Form Our Beliefs?


“Humans only use 10 per cent of their brains.”


Many people have heard this claim, perhaps at school, through conversations or from popular films such as Lucy, directed by Luc Besson. However, the idea that humans use only 10 per cent of their brains is a myth. Brain activity varies according to the task, but much of the brain has identifiable functions, and we use many different brain regions throughout everyday life.


Why, then, do beliefs that are inaccurate continue to circulate?


One reason is that our beliefs are influenced by how we perceive the world. Perception refers to the way we organise and interpret information received through our senses. It is not simply a direct recording of reality; our expectations, memories, emotions and past experiences can influence what we notice and how we interpret it. Imagine walking past a patch of grass and hearing something rustle. You might immediately believe that an animal is hiding there. If you are frightened, you may become convinced that the sound signals danger. Yet the rustling could have been caused by the wind.


The sound is real, but your interpretation of its cause may or may not be accurate.


The same process occurs in everyday decisions. Suppose someone believes that having two master’s degrees makes a person more likely to secure a job. They may have heard this from a teacher, observed it in a relative or concluded it from their own experience. Over time, the belief may become accepted as a fact without examining the circumstances in which additional qualifications actually help. Daniel Gilbert (1991) discussed the human tendency to believe information and the difficulty of evaluating it critically. Later research by Gilbert, Tafarodi and Malone (1993) explored how cognitive demands can affect people’s ability to distinguish true information from false information.


These findings highlight an important point: we do not always evaluate every piece of information carefully before accepting it. Beliefs can develop quickly, particularly when information seems familiar, comes from a trusted source or fits what we already expect. Research has also explored how beliefs may influence decision-making, goal-setting and our interpretation of the environment. However, beliefs do not always improve our decisions. Their usefulness depends partly on how well they correspond to the circumstances in which we apply them.


Why Do People Hold Contrasting Beliefs?


Two people can encounter the same information and reach entirely different conclusions. Their interpretations may be influenced by their upbringing, personal experiences, values, social groups and emotional attachments.


Religion provides one example. When children grow up within a religious tradition, they may learn particular explanations about morality, identity, relationships and the meaning of life. These ideas can become deeply connected to their sense of belonging and their relationships with family and community. As people grow older, questioning these beliefs may feel like questioning more than an idea. It may feel like challenging their identity, their upbringing or the people they love.


The stronger the emotional attachment to a belief, the more personally threatening disagreement can sometimes feel. People may defend their beliefs because they perceive a challenge to those beliefs as a challenge to themselves. However, emotional attachment does not automatically make a belief false. Nor does confidence establish that a belief is true. The important distinction is between how strongly we believe something and the evidence supporting it.


Consider colour. We learn to identify colours such as blue and purple, and these categories become familiar parts of our everyday experience. From a scientific perspective, colour perception involves light wavelengths, the visual system and the brain’s interpretation of sensory information. The experience of colour is not simply the wavelength itself; it also depends on how our visual system processes light. This illustrates how our everyday understanding of the world can differ from a more detailed scientific explanation.


Does Belief Help Us Manage Stress and Anxiety?


For some people, religious beliefs provide comfort, community, purpose and a way of interpreting difficult experiences. Research has examined associations between religious belief, coping and psychological well-being (Ano & Vasconcelles, 2004).


Other people find meaning and support through secular values, scientific understanding, relationships, philosophical reflection or personal goals. Does believing in something necessarily reduce stress?


Not always.


Farias and Reiman (2019) investigated whether reflecting on religious belief or belief in science influenced participants’ responses to stress. In the study described by the authors, activating these beliefs did not produce the expected reduction in subjective or physiological stress responses compared with the control condition.


Such findings should be interpreted within the limits of the particular study. They do not establish that religion, science or personal beliefs are never helpful for coping. They suggest that simply activating a belief may not be enough to reduce stress in every situation. Beliefs can provide meaning and reassurance, but their effects depend on the person, the circumstances and the way the belief is used.


How Are Our Beliefs Conditioned by Society?


Many beliefs that appear natural to us are learned through social interaction. We learn how to speak to elders, how to behave around peers, what is considered appropriate for different genders and which actions are rewarded or discouraged. Families, schools, religious communities, media and wider society all contribute to this learning.


However, social expectations vary across cultures, languages, communities and geographical locations. What one society considers appropriate may be interpreted differently elsewhere. Consider wedding clothing. In many Chinese wedding traditions, red is associated with celebration and good fortune. In many Western wedding traditions, white has become a common bridal colour. In India, bridal clothing varies across regions, religions and communities, with red and other colours carrying different cultural meanings.


These colours do not possess a universal power to determine the success of a marriage. Their significance comes from cultural traditions, shared meanings and personal preferences. This raises an interesting question: if we had grown up in a different cultural environment, would we hold the same beliefs about wedding colours, appropriate behaviour or good fortune? We cannot know exactly how every individual would respond, but our cultural environment clearly influences what we learn to value and expect.


Can Childhood Conditioning Influence Adult Behaviour?


Imagine a child who is repeatedly praised for keeping their room clean. Initially, the child may tidy their room to please their parents or avoid criticism. Over time, they may begin to associate being organised with being good, responsible or worthy of approval.

There is nothing inherently wrong with learning responsibility. The difficulty arises if the child comes to believe that their worth depends entirely on pleasing other people.


As an adult, that person might struggle to say no, feel guilty when someone is disappointed or prioritise approval over personal needs. Similarly, children and teenagers may develop beliefs about their abilities, appearance, relationships and social status through experiences at school, interactions with peers and pressure from social media. Repeated criticism or exclusion may contribute to beliefs such as “I am not good enough” or “I must be liked by everyone.”


These beliefs are not inevitable consequences of childhood experiences, and they can change. Recognising where a belief originated can help us understand why it feels convincing, but its origin alone does not determine whether it is true. Parenting, education and supportive relationships can help children learn to question assumptions, regulate emotions and develop a more flexible understanding of themselves and others.


How Do Our Needs Influence Our Beliefs?


In 1891, psychologist James Mark Baldwin explored the relationship between belief and the satisfaction of needs. His work reflects an enduring question: do we sometimes believe something because it helps us meet a psychological or practical need?


Consider the need for safety. Many households use locks, alarms, security cameras and other protective measures. These systems reflect an understanding that security can reduce certain risks and provide reassurance.


Shani Shingnapur, a village in Maharashtra, is widely known for traditions associated with houses and shops having no conventional doors or locks. The village is often discussed in connection with local beliefs about protection and trust. However, it would be inaccurate to conclude that everyone in the village shares the same beliefs or that security practices are determined solely by belief. Cultural traditions, local circumstances and practical decisions can all influence how people approach safety.


The example nevertheless raises a useful question: how do our beliefs about danger influence the actions we take to feel secure?


Maslow’s hierarchy of needs offers one framework for thinking about this question. It describes needs such as safety, belonging, esteem and self-actualisation as important influences on human motivation. Although the model is not a universal formula for predicting behaviour, it can help us explore how perceived needs shape priorities.


What Is the Difference Between Beliefs and Values?


Beliefs are ideas we accept as true or likely to be true. Values are principles or priorities that influence what we consider important and how we want to act. For example, a person may believe that honesty is essential for trust. Honesty may therefore become a value that guides their behaviour.


Values can also be shaped by culture and social experience. Attitudes towards marriage, gender roles, family responsibilities and relationships vary considerably across societies and communities. In some environments, heterosexual relationships may be widely accepted while same-sex relationships face discrimination. Such differences demonstrate how social norms influence what people consider acceptable. They do not, by themselves, establish whether a social belief is fair or ethically justified.


Beliefs and values can influence one another, but they are not identical. A person may believe that a practice is common in their community without believing that it is morally right. Understanding this distinction allows us to ask not only whether a belief is accurate, but also whether the values guiding our actions are consistent with fairness, compassion and respect for others.


Can Beliefs Limit the Way We See Reality?


Beliefs can help us make sense of the world, but they can also narrow our attention.


Once we accept an idea, we may become more likely to notice information that supports it and overlook information that challenges it. This tendency is related to confirmation bias. Consider the belief that black cats bring bad luck. A person who holds this belief may remember an unfortunate event that occurred after a black cat crossed their path. If something unpleasant happens again, they may interpret it as further evidence.


However, they may overlook the many occasions when a black cat crossed their path and nothing unusual happened. The sequence of events does not establish a causal relationship. The belief may persist because the person remembers confirming examples more readily than contradictory ones.


The human brain is highly sensitive to patterns, and this ability is useful for learning and predicting events. Yet we can sometimes detect patterns in events that are coincidental or unrelated. We may also attribute intention or meaning to an occurrence without sufficient evidence.


Michael Shermer (2011) discusses the human tendency to form beliefs and then search for evidence that supports them. This is one reason it can be difficult to revise an established belief, particularly when it has become part of our identity. Researchers sometimes use the term belief-dependent realism to discuss how our interpretation of reality can be influenced by the beliefs we already hold. This does not mean that reality itself changes whenever we believe something. Rather, our experience and interpretation of reality can be shaped by expectations and assumptions.


The important distinction is that our beliefs influence how we interpret reality, but they do not automatically determine what is objectively true.


How Do Political Beliefs Change?


Political beliefs provide another example of how values, experiences and perceived needs can influence our thinking. People may develop political views through family, education, community, media, personal experience or direct engagement with political ideas. Some identify strongly with a political party, while others change their views as their circumstances or understanding evolves.


Imagine someone beginning their career who is primarily concerned about employment opportunities, economic mobility and access to jobs. They may favour policies they believe will create opportunities for people in their situation. Years later, their financial circumstances may change. They might become more concerned about taxation, public services, economic stability or the distribution of resources. They may reconsider some of their earlier political positions.


This does not mean that everyone changes political beliefs according to personal financial advantage. Political views are influenced by many factors, including moral values, identity, social relationships and beliefs about how society should function. Nor can political ideologies be accurately reduced to a simple contrast in which one side benefits only one group and the other treats everyone equally. Political movements contain diverse ideas, and their actual policies need to be examined individually.


The broader point is that our priorities can change as we gain new experiences. We may revise our beliefs when our circumstances change, when we encounter new evidence or when we reconsider what matters most to us.


Do We Believe Everything We Hear?


Human beings rely on information from other people because we cannot independently investigate every claim we encounter. Language, education, research and social communication allow us to learn far more than we could through personal experience alone. However, this dependence on information from others also creates opportunities for error and misinformation.


Gilbert, Tafarodi and Malone (1993) conducted experiments examining how people evaluate information under cognitive pressure. Their findings suggested that when participants were distracted or placed under time pressure, they could become more likely to mistakenly remember false statements as true.


The research does not mean that humans believe everything they hear in every situation. It illustrates that our ability to evaluate information can be affected by cognitive demands. This is particularly relevant in an environment filled with news, social media posts, advertisements and online commentary. Information may appear convincing because it is repeated frequently, presented confidently or shared by someone we trust.


Even when we try to research a belief, we may encounter sources that repeat the same unsupported claim. Finding information online is not the same as verifying it. A more reliable approach involves checking the original evidence, considering alternative explanations, examining the credibility of the source and remaining open to uncertainty.


Are All Beliefs Wrong, or Should We Choose What Works for Us?


The title of this article presents a provocative idea: “All beliefs are wrong, choose what works for you.”


Taken literally, however, the statement is too absolute. Some beliefs are well supported by evidence, while others are mistaken, incomplete or impossible to verify. The fact that beliefs are influenced by culture, experience or personal needs does not automatically make them false. Nor is usefulness alone a reliable test of truth. A belief may provide comfort or confidence while still being inaccurate. Conversely, a true belief may be uncomfortable or inconvenient.


For example, believing that you are capable of learning a new skill may encourage you to practise and persevere. But believing that you can master a complex skill without effort may lead to unrealistic expectations. Similarly, a belief that helps someone cope with uncertainty may provide emotional comfort, but that does not establish that every claim associated with the belief is factually correct.


Rather than asking only whether a belief works for us, we can ask three questions:


  • Is it supported by evidence? What facts, observations or reliable sources support the belief?

  • Is it useful in this context? Does it help us make informed decisions, or does it encourage avoidance, fear or harmful behaviour?

  • Am I willing to revise it? What evidence or experience would lead me to reconsider my position?


These questions allow us to preserve beliefs that are helpful and well supported while remaining willing to change those that no longer serve us or conflict with reliable evidence.


We do not need to abandon every belief. We need to avoid treating every belief as unquestionable truth.


How Can We Develop a More Flexible Belief System?


Beliefs are not necessarily permanent. As we encounter new experiences, learn new information and reflect on our assumptions, we can revise the way we understand the world. Developing a more flexible belief system does not mean rejecting everything we were taught. It means learning to distinguish between ideas that deserve confidence and assumptions that need further examination.


We can begin by identifying beliefs we rarely question. Where did they originate? Were they based on personal experience, family expectations, cultural traditions or information from a reliable source? We can then examine whether those beliefs remain accurate and useful in our current circumstances.


It is also helpful to seek out perspectives that differ from our own. This does not require accepting every opposing argument. It means being willing to understand how other people reached their conclusions and considering whether their evidence reveals something we had overlooked. Finally, we can recognise that changing a belief is not necessarily a sign of weakness or inconsistency. It may reflect learning, personal growth and a willingness to respond to new information.


Approaches such as Neuro-Linguistic Programming (NLP) explore how patterns of language, thought and behaviour may influence the way people interpret experiences. However, NLP’s broader claims about changing beliefs and psychological outcomes are not consistently supported by strong scientific evidence. Reflective exercises may encourage self-awareness, but they should not be mistaken for proof that all beliefs are subjective or that usefulness establishes truth.


Conclusion: Can We Choose What We Believe?


Our beliefs influence the way we interpret experiences, form relationships, make decisions and understand ourselves. Many develop through childhood, culture, social relationships and personal experience. Some help us navigate the world, while others may restrict our thinking or lead us to misunderstand what is happening around us.


As our needs, circumstances and understanding change, our beliefs may change too. That does not mean that all beliefs are wrong or that truth is simply whatever works best for us. It means that we should be willing to examine the assumptions through which we interpret the world. We can respect our cultural backgrounds without assuming that every tradition is beyond question. We can recognise the comfort a belief provides without confusing comfort with evidence. And we can change our minds without treating our earlier selves with contempt.


Perhaps the most valuable skill is not learning to believe everything or to doubt everything. It is learning to distinguish between what we know, what we assume and what we still need to understand.


As Wayne W. Dyer is often quoted as saying:


“A belief system is nothing more than a thought you’ve thought over and over again.”


Repeated thoughts can become familiar, and familiarity can make an idea feel true. But repetition alone does not establish truth.


Rather than believing every thought simply because it feels familiar, we can learn to question our assumptions, examine the evidence and choose our actions with greater awareness.

THE END

This article on ' All beliefs are wrong, choose what works for you ' has been contributed by Vrinda Goel, who is an aspiring psychologist and the article is Peer reviewed by Anshu Yadav, who has received her Master’s degree in Clinical Psychology from Amity University, Noida.. Both Vrinda and Anshu are part of the Global Internship Research Program (GIRP), which is mentored by Anil Thomas.


Vrinda's main motive is to help out the marginalised community to understand their mental health and improve it. Anshu is extremely curious about psychology and wants to spread awareness about mental health problems to help those in need.


GIRP is an initiative by (International Journal of Neurolinguistics & Gestalt Psychology) IJNGP and Umang Foundation Trust to encourage young adults across our globe to showcase their research skills in psychology and to present it in creative content expression.


Anil is an internationally certified NLP Master Practitioner and Gestalt Therapist. He has conducted NLP Training in Mumbai, and across 6 other countries. The NLP practitioner course is conducted twice every year.

bottom of page